So, former Yankee outfielder Roy White is not too thrilled with the way Robinson Cano and Melky Cabrera celebrate Yankee victories. And Hall of Fame reliever Goose Gossage thinks Joba Chamberlain should forget the fist pump.
These revelations were included in a recent Bob Klapisch column.
I love both of these guys. Gossage, of course, is a historic Yankee and took part in many of the most memorable baseball moments of my lifetime. White is a classy guy who was a good player for the Yankees for many years.
I have news for them, though. Fellas, this is not the 1970s, anymore. Thanks for playing, thanks for stopping by and thanks for the memories. Now, shut up and go away! Nobody really cares about your “back in my day” whining.
It’s a different era. Cano, Cabrera and Chamberlain are part of an era where players show more emotion, where they let their feelings out and let you see the joy that they feel when the accomplish something.
I’m old-school about a lot of things — but not this. There’s not a thing wrong with players showing emotion on the field, provided that it’s pure and not contrived or directed toward a specific opposing player or team.
I believe, quite simply, that players like these young Yankees, Jose Reyes of the Mets, Jonathan Papelbon of the Red Sox and others just enjoy what they do. How can you fault that?
Baseball is a game, and I always thought games were meant to be enjoyed. Players play because they love to, so why shouldn’t they be able to show it? I’m not saying sometimes players don’t go too far — they do on occasion. I just don’t think these young Yankees have crossed that line.
I admit I don’t like these contrived celebrations. Dennis Eckersley used to point at any hitter he struck out. Now that is showing up a hitter. All of these guys wo point to the heavens after doing something look stupid, too. In football, all of these choreographed dances, pulling out a Sharpie, a cellphone, the first-down salute or whatever — that bugs me. Honest displays of emotion? No.
As for Gosssage’s claim that Joba’s fist pump is “just not the Yankee way,” that’s a bunch of nonsense.
What is the Yankee way, anyway? Class? Dignity? Respect? Give me a break!
How many times did Reggie Jackson stand at home plate and admire a home run? Is that the Yankee way? How is Billy Martin and Reggie brawling in the dugout classy? Babe Ruth and Mickey Mantle were legendary carousers? Is that the Yankee way? How many times have we seen Derek Jeter with the fist pump after a big hit or a World Series victory? Are we going to rip him, too? For crying out loud, the Yankees are the franchise that had two players (Fritz Peterson and Mike Kekich) trade wives. Is that the Yankee way?
The Yankee way is winning. Period. Not having the most class, dignity or showing the most respect for the opposition. It’s about collecting the best players they possible can and winning. It’s about the 26 World Series titles, and the hunt for more.
If Cano, Cabrera, Chamberlain and others actually want to look like they are having a little fun while they are wearing the pinstripes good for them.
There is nothing wrong with letting people see you actually enjoy what you are doing.
Leave a Reply
- Indoor Four ’15: July edition by Landon Evanson
- 25,000 Little Magical Bucks Can’t Be Wrong by Patrick Smith
- Peace Out, Pete by Duke Jackson
- Hangin’ with Hargrove: A B&C interview with Mike Hargrove by Landon Evanson
- I Get it Now by Landon Evanson